Practitioners on Reddit keep asking the same thing: a worker has reported a workplace to OSHA, so what happens next? We listen to those discussions to see what people are actually trying to find out, and this piece adds the sequence as OSHA describes it.

Readers will leave knowing how OSHA sorts a complaint, what an employer must do and by when on each route, what the complainant can do if the response looks inadequate and how to prepare. It is written for US employers and workers.

The OSHA complaint process is the way the Occupational Safety and Health Administration reviews a report of a workplace hazard and decides whether to investigate by phone and fax or to send an inspector.

How OSHA decides between a phone/fax investigation and an on-site inspection

OSHA evaluates each complaint first. Before it inspects, staff must find reasonable grounds to believe that a violation or hazard exists. Complaints are ranked by the severity of the hazard and the number of employees exposed, not by the order they arrive. See OSHA's complaint handling process for the official description of both routes and the note on state plan states.

Two details change the outcome. If the employer already knows of the hazard and is correcting it, OSHA may skip an inspection once it has documentation. And a worker can ask for either route, so the worker's request is part of the decision.

State plan states may work differently. Twenty-three states and jurisdictions run OSHA-approved programs for private and public employers, and their complaint procedures may differ slightly. Federal OSHA forwards complaints from workers in those states to the relevant state plan, so an employer there should check the state program's rules.

The eight criteria that point to an on-site inspection

A phone/fax investigation is the default when none of the on-site criteria is met, or when the worker or representative asks for it. An on-site inspection needs a written request and at least one of these:

  • A signed written complaint from a current employee or representative, with enough detail.
  • Alleged physical harm that still exists.
  • A report of imminent danger, meaning an immediate risk of death or serious physical harm. This is OSHA's top inspection priority.
  • A complaint about an industry or hazard covered by an OSHA emphasis program.
  • An inadequate employer response to a phone/fax investigation.
  • An employer with recent egregious, willful or failure-to-abate citations within the last three years.
  • A referral from a whistleblower investigator.
  • A facility that is already scheduled for, or undergoing, an inspection.

What each route asks of the employer and the complainant

The two routes move differently. The three parts below follow the sequence for each side.

The phone/fax investigation: five days to respond

OSHA phones the employer, describes the alleged hazards and follows up by fax or letter. The employer must respond within five days, identifying any problems and describing the corrective action taken or planned. If the response is adequate, OSHA generally will not inspect, and the complainant receives a copy of it.

The on-site inspection: what to expect on the day

An inspector visits the workplace. Inspections are generally limited to the hazards in the complaint, though inspectors may expand them and may cite violations in plain sight. A workers' representative, chosen by a union or the employees and never by the employer, may accompany the inspector, and workers can speak with the inspector privately. Afterwards the complainant receives a letter outlining findings, citations and proposed penalties.

If the response looks inadequate: the complainant's options

A complainant who is not satisfied with an employer's phone/fax response can ask for an on-site inspection in writing. An inadequate response is itself one of the criteria for inspecting. A complainant can also ask OSHA not to reveal their name to the employer.

A worked example: a phone/fax letter and the employer's response

The following is an illustrative example, with a fictional company, not an OSHA template. An area office phones a metal fabricator, then sends a letter listing two alleged hazards and asking for a written response within five days.

Item 1: the exit route beside Dock 3 is reported blocked by stored pallets. Item 2: the press on Line 4 is reported operating without a guard on the point of operation.

The plant's EHS manager replies in writing before the deadline, item by item.

Item 1: Pallets were removed from the Dock 3 exit route on the day of the call. The route is now marked with floor tape and checked at the start of every shift by the shift supervisor. Dated photographs and the check log are attached. The route is intended to meet 29 CFR 1910.37.

Item 2: The press was taken out of service on the day of the call. A fixed guard was installed and verified by the maintenance lead on the following day. The operators on Line 4 were retrained and the training record is attached. The guard is intended to meet 29 CFR 1910.212.

Each answer states what was found, what was done, who did it, when and what evidence exists. That is what lets OSHA judge the response adequate without an inspection.

Four situations after a complaint and how to handle them

What it looks like What to do What it achieves
A faxed letter arrives and is left with a manager for a week Log the date received, assign an owner and answer within the five days The response reaches OSHA on time and the route stays off-site
The reply says there is no hazard but offers no proof Answer each item with what was found, the action taken and dated evidence OSHA can judge the response adequate without further steps
The employer is already fixing the hazard Send documentation of the work and the schedule to OSHA OSHA may skip the inspection once it has the documents
The worker is unhappy with the employer's answer Expect a written request for an on-site inspection and prepare for it The inspection does not catch the site unprepared

Preparing an employer response to either route

Preparation is mostly about being able to find records quickly. Name one person to receive OSHA calls and letters and make sure the front desk knows who it is. Keep hazard reports, inspection checklists, corrective action records and training files where that person can reach them within hours. When a worker raises a hazard internally, log it and close it out with evidence, so the answer to an OSHA letter already exists.

For an on-site visit, decide in advance who accompanies the inspector, which records are produced and where the inspector will be taken first. Brief supervisors so that nobody discourages a worker from speaking with the inspector.

A system that holds hazard reports and corrective actions together makes the five-day answer faster to assemble. Ideagen's incident management software shows how hazard reports and corrective actions are tracked in one system.

The sequence to remember after an OSHA complaint

After a complaint, OSHA evaluates first, then chooses a phone/fax investigation or an inspection. On the off-site route the employer has five days to answer in writing, and an inadequate answer can lead to an on-site visit. Workers keep the right to ask for an inspection, to have their name withheld and to see the employer's response. Employers in state plan states should check the state's own procedure.

To continue the discussion with other practitioners, join Ideagen's Reddit community.

Explore EHS solutions

Build better EHS processes, mitigate safety risks and protect employees with a unified solution for reporting incidents and managing safety.