A food manufacturer passes its final product tests every week. Then a customer asks a different question: can the company show that the cleaning step on the packaging line was carried out as written, every time, by someone trained to do it? Test results alone cannot answer that. The records, the procedures and the people behind the product have to be checked as well, and that check has a method of its own.
What is a quality audit?
A quality audit is a systematic, independent and documented check of whether an organization’s processes, products or quality system meet the requirements they are measured against.
ISO 19011, the international standard of guidelines for auditing management systems, describes an audit in its 2018 edition as a systematic, independent and documented process for obtaining objective evidence and evaluating it objectively to determine the extent to which the audit criteria are fulfilled. ISO published a fourth edition of the standard in May 2026.
In everyday terms, an auditor takes a requirement, such as a written procedure, a standard or a customer contract, and checks real records and real work against it to see whether the two match. A food manufacturer might check that line cleaning records match its cleaning procedure. A hospital laboratory might check that sample handling follows its documented steps. A software team might check that change approvals match its change policy.
A quality audit compares evidence with requirements, and the organization, its customers, a standard or a regulation can each set those requirements. Its conclusions rest on a sample of the available evidence, so they show how well a system performed on what was examined.
Why audits catch gaps before customers or certification bodies do
Because an audit tests records and daily practice against requirements, its value shows up in a few concrete outcomes.
- Gaps surface before a customer or certification body finds them, meaning corrective action happens on the organization’s own schedule.
- Written procedures are tested against daily practice, meaning any drift between the two becomes visible.
- Records become evidence, meaning the organization can show what was done and when.
The four terms that take an audit from requirements to a verdict
ISO 19011:2018 sets out a shared vocabulary, and four of its terms describe how an audit moves from requirements to a verdict.
Audit criteria are the requirements evidence is checked against
Audit criteria are the set of requirements that evidence is compared against, such as policies, procedures, legal requirements, management system requirements or contractual obligations. Agreeing the criteria first keeps an audit focused on what the organization has committed to.
Audit evidence is what can be verified
Audit evidence is records, statements of fact or other information that is relevant to the audit criteria and can be verified. A training record and an auditor’s direct observation of a task can both serve as evidence.
Audit findings record where practice matches or misses the criteria
Audit findings are the results of evaluating the collected evidence against the criteria. They indicate conformity or nonconformity, and they can also point to risks, opportunities for improvement or good practice worth recording.
The audit conclusion turns findings into a verdict management can act on
The audit conclusion is the outcome of an audit after the objectives and all findings have been considered. It is the statement management acts on, which is why it needs to follow directly from the evidence.
First, second and third party audits and who carries each one out
Audits are also grouped by who carries them out. ISO 19011:2018 distinguishes three groups.
| Type | Carried out by |
| First party (internal) | By or on behalf of the organization itself |
| Second party | By parties with an interest in the organization (such as customers) or by others acting on their behalf |
| Third party | By independent auditing organizations (for example, certification or registration bodies) or by government agencies |
Internal audits are the usual starting point for an organization that wants to find problems before anyone external does. Internal quality audits cover the first party group in more depth, including how to schedule them and turn findings into action.
How a quality audit runs from planning to follow-up
The detail varies by organization and standard, but most audits move through the same four stages.
- Plan the audit. The auditor defines the scope, objectives and criteria and gathers the documents and data needed beforehand.
- Carry out the audit. The auditor gathers evidence by reviewing records, talking with staff and observing work, using a checklist to cover every area.
- Evaluate and report. Findings are analyzed against the criteria and recorded in a report that is easy to follow.
- Follow up. An action plan addresses each nonconformity and improvement area, and progress is monitored until the changes are in place and effective.
The same stages apply when auditing a quality management system as a whole.
What a sample-based audit cannot show
An audit examines a sample, not everything. ISO 19011:2018 notes that audit evidence is generally based on samples of the available information because an audit takes place over a finite period with finite resources, and that sampling is closely related to the confidence that can be placed in the audit conclusions. A clean result therefore shows how a system performed on the evidence examined, and only the next audit shows whether earlier findings stayed closed.
Common questions about audit standards and independence
Does ISO 19011 lead to certification?
No. ISO 19011 provides guidance on auditing management systems and does not itself lead to certification. It supports auditing against standards such as ISO 9001 and ISO 14001, which organizations can be certified to. The guidance covers the principles of auditing, managing an audit program and conducting audits, as well as evaluating the competence of the people involved.
Can a small organization run an independent internal audit?
Often only partly. ISO 19011:2018 says auditors should be independent of the activity being audited wherever practicable, and it acknowledges that small organizations may not be able to achieve full independence. In that case every effort should be made to remove bias and encourage objectivity, so that findings and conclusions rest only on the audit evidence.
Every audit finding should end in a verified fix
A requirement, a sample of evidence, a finding and a conclusion form a chain, and the chain only pays off when someone acts on the last link. Whether an audit is internal, run by a customer or carried out by a certification body, the same discipline applies: compare what was written with what was done, record the gap honestly and close it with a fix that can be checked later. That is the test to apply to any audit report: does each finding end in a change that has been verified?