• SOLUTIONS
    • Quality

      QUALITY

      Quality management solution

      Embed quality throughout your business processes by aligning and centralising all key functions to elevate your organisation to its full potential.

      Find out more

      CASE STUDY

      JAE Oregon take ownership of ISO 9001 and 14001 compliance activities.

      BUSINESS NEEDS

      • APQP
      • ISO & Certifications
      • CAPA management
      • First article inspection report
      • Product part approval process
      • Quality management
      • Supplier management
      • Document management
      • Quality control

      INDUSTRIES

      • Aerospace and defence
      • Life science
      • Manufacturing
      • Healthcare
      • Food and drink
      • Pharmaceuticals
    • Health, safety and environmental

      HEALTH, SAFETY AND ENVIRONMENTAL

      Health, safety and environmental management solutions

      Reduce risk, protect your people and drive sustainability, efficiently and effectively

      Find out more

      CASE STUDY

      News Corp streamline essential workplace training to suit everyone.

      BUSINESS NEEDS

      • Safety management
      • Incident management
      • Health and safety training solution
      • Enviromental

      INDUSTRIES

      • Food and drink
      • Energy
      • Transport and logistics
      • Aviation
    • Audit and risk

      AUDIT AND RISK

      Audit and risk management solutions

      Our powerful audit and risk management solutions help you protect your business, its customers and your corporate clients.

      Find out more

      CASE STUDY

      Cadence Bank integrate audit and risk to create a more powerful system.

      BUSINESS NEEDS

      • Internal audit
      • Risk management
      • External audit tools

      INDUSTRIES

      • Finance
      • Government
      • Education
    • Collaboration

      COLLABORATION

      Collaboration solution

      Bring your people, content and actions together with highly secure, cloud-based collaboration solutions.

      Find out more

      CASE STUDY

      Altera meet CMMI best practices with better control and efficiency.

      BUSINESS NEEDS

      • Bids and proposals
      • Document redaction
      • Document co-authoring and review

      INDUSTRIES

      • Aerospace and defence
      • Life Sciences and pharmaceuticals
      • AEC
    • PRODUCTS
    • Q-Pulse QMS
    • Q-Pulse PM
    • Q-Pulse WorkRite
    • Q-Pulse Law
    • Pentana Audit
    • Pentana Disclose
    • Pentana Risk
    • PleaseReview
    • Coruson
    • Ideagen Academy
    • Huddle
    • Qualtrax
    • InspectionXpert
    • Mi-Co
    • CompliSpace
    • OpsBase
    • Audit Analytics
    • Mail Manager
    • CompliancePath

    FEATURED RESOURCES

    CASE STUDY

    Q-Pulse enabled Anthony Nolan to meet a range of regulations and stay compliant.

    • INDUSTRIES
    • Aerospace and defence
    • Aviation
    • Energy
    • Financial services
    • Healthcare
    • Life science
    • Manufacturing
    • Pharmaceuticals
    • Transport & logistics
    • Food & drinks
    • AEC
    • Government

    FEATURED RESOURCES

    CASE STUDY

    Mettle Ops achieve AS9100 compliance with zero non-conformances.

    CASE STUDY

    NWDC drastically reduces time spent on creating documents.

    • RESOURCES
    • By Industry

      BY INDUSTRY

      • Aerospace and defence
      • Aviation
      • Energy
      • Financial services
      • Healthcare
      • Life science
      • Manufacturing
      • Rail

      FEATURED RESOURCES

      WHITEPAPER

      Manage anti-money laundering regulations in the UK and EU.

      CASE STUDY

      Nuffield Health establish a central database for pathology compliance activities.

    • By Solution

      BY SOLUTION

      • Quality
      • Safety
      • Environmental
      • Regulatory
      • Documents
      • Audit
      • Risk

      FEATURED RESOURCES

      WHITEPAPER

      Manage anti-money laundering regulations in the UK and EU.

      CASE STUDY

      Nuffield Health establish a central database for pathology compliance activities.

    • By Product

      BY PRODUCT

      • Q-Pulse QMS
      • Q-Pulse Law
      • Q-Pulse WorkRite
      • Q-Pulse PM
      • Pentana Audit
      • Pentana Disclose
      • Pentana Risk
      • Pleasereview
      • Coruson
      • Ideagen Academy

      FEATURED RESOURCES

      WHITEPAPER

      Manage anti-money laundering regulations in the UK and EU.

      CASE STUDY

      Nuffield Health establish a central database for pathology compliance activities.

    • By Resource Type

      BY RESOURCE TYPE

      • Brochures
      • Case studies
      • Flyers
      • Blog
      • White papers

      FEATURED RESOURCES

      WHITEPAPER

      Manage anti-money laundering regulations in the UK and EU.

      CASE STUDY

      Nuffield Health establish a central database for pathology compliance activities.

    View All Resources
    • COMPANY
    • About Us

      ABOUT US

      • Our company
      • Leadership team
      • Objectives
      • Strategy
      • Values
      • Our customer focus
      • Certifications
      • Investors

      FEATURED RESOURCES

      CAREERS

      We are recruiting! Take the next exciting step in your career

      VALUES

      We are ambitious - We are adventurous - We are community

    • Events and Updates

      EVENTS AND UPDATES

      • Events
      • News
      • Blogs

      FEATURED RESOURCES

      CAREERS

      We are recruiting! Take the next exciting step in your career

      VALUES

      We are ambitious - We are adventurous - We are community

    • Careers

      CAREERS

      • Careers overview
      • Current vacancies

        HIRING

      • Benefits
      • Apprenticeships
      • Meet our teams

      FEATURED RESOURCES

      CAREERS

      We are recruiting! Take the next exciting step in your career

      VALUES

      We are ambitious - We are adventurous - We are community

  • Contact Sales
Menu
  • Solutions
    • « Back
    • Solutions
    • Quality
      • « Back
      • Quality
      • Quality management solution

        Embed quality throughout your business processes by aligning and centralising all key functions to elevate your organisation to its full potential.

      • Find Out More

      APQP

      CAPA management

      ISO & Certifications

      First article inspection report

      Product part approval process

      Supplier management

      Quality Control

      Quality management

      Document management

      Aerospace and defence

      Life science

      Manufacturing

      Healthcare

      Food and drink

      Pharmaceuticals

      Contact us
    • Health, safety and environmental
      • « Back
      • Health, safety and environmental
      • Health, safety and environmental management solutions

        Reduce risk, protect your people and drive sustainability, efficiently and effectively

      • Find Out More

      Safety management

      Incident management

      Health and safety training solution

      Enviromental

      Food and drink

      Energy

      Transport and logistics

      Aviation

      Contact us
    • Audit & Risk
      • « Back
      • Audit & Risk
      • Audit and risk management solutions

        Our powerful audit and risk management solutions help you protect your business, its customers and your corporate clients.

      • Find out more

      Internal audit

      Risk software

      External audit software

      Finance

      Government

      Education

      Contact us
    • Collaboration
      • « Back
      • Collaboration
      • Collaboration solution

        Bring your people, content and actions together with highly secure, cloud-based collaboration solutions.

      • Find Out More

      Bids and proposals

      Document redaction

      Document co-authoring and review

      Aerospace and defence

      Life Science and Pharmaceuticals

      AEC

      Contact Us
    Contact us
  • Products
    • « Back
    • Products
    • Q-Pulse QMS

      Q-Pulse PM

      Q-Pulse WorkRite

      Q-Pulse Law

      Pentana Audit

      Pentana Disclose

      Pentana Risk

      PleaseReview

      Coruson

      Ideagen Academy

      Audit Analytics

      Mail Manager

      CompliancePath

      Huddle

      Qualtrax

      InspectionXpert

      Mi-Co

      CompliSpace

      OpsBase

    Contact Us
  • Industries
    • « Back
    • Industries
    • Aerospace and defence

      Aviation

      Energy

      Finance

      Healthcare

      Life science

      Manufacturing

      Pharmaceuticals

      Transport & logistics

      Food & drinks

      AEC

      Government

    Contact Us
  • Resources
    • « Back
    • Resources
    • By Industry
      • « Back
      • By Industry
      • Aerospace and defence

        Aviation

        Energy

        Financial services

        Healthcare

        Life science

        Manufacturing

        Rail

      • View all resources
      Contact us
    • By Solution
      • « Back
      • By Solution
      • Quality

        Safety

        Environmental

        Regulatory

        Documents

        Audit

        Risk

      • View all resources
      Contact us
    • By Product
      • « Back
      • By Product
      • Q-Pulse QMS

        Q-Pulse Law

        Q-Pulse WorkRite

        Q-Pulse PM

        Pentana Audit

        Pentana Disclose

        Pentana Risk

        Pleasereview

        Coruson

        Ideagen Academy

      • View all resources
      Contact us
    • By Resource Type
      • « Back
      • By Resource Type
      • Brochures

        Case studies

        Flyers

        Blog

        White papers

      • View all resources
      Contact us
    Contact us
  • Company
    • « Back
    • Company
    • About us
      • « Back
      • About us
      • Our company

        Leadership team

        Objectives

        Strategy

        Values

        Our customer focus

        Certifications

        Investors

      Contact us
    • Events and updates
      • « Back
      • Events and updates
      • Events

        News

        Blogs

      Contact us
    • Careers
      • « Back
      • Careers
      • Careers overview

        Current vacancies

        Benefits

        Apprenticeships

        Meet our teams

      Contact us
    Contact us
Contact Us
  • Home
  • Thought Leadership
  • Blog
  • Company culture: lessons to be learned from ‘murmuration’ of starlings

Culture and governance: Lessons to be learned from ‘murmuration’ of starlings

15 January 2019

company-culture-lessons-to-be-learned-from-murmuration-of-starlings.png (1)
Culture and governance: Lessons to be learned from ‘murmuration’ of starlings

Share this

Throughout our behavioural compliance series, Ideagen has delved into the world of behavioural science to give organisations practical tips for implementing a culture of compliance. The importance of culture and governance is well-documented, so much so that the UK Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) previously laid the blame for major conduct failings within financial services on firm culture. It stressed the importance of corporate governance and culture and implemented changes to its regulatory strategy to promote a positive cultural change within firms.

The FCA’s objective is to bring about fair market conduct and the right customer outcomes. Underpinning this objective is the Senior Managers and Certification Regime (SMCR), which is designed to create a formal link of accountability between individuals and the conduct of the firm. The SMCR provides clear rules and responsibilities for senior managers, certified staff and all other staff who will be subject to a set of rules governing their conduct. The FCA makes it clear, however, that it does not believe “one size fits all” when it comes to a firm’s culture and corporate governance.

It has set a minimum expected standard but does not prescribe what a firm’s culture should be. This has left some wondering how to implement the seemingly intangible concept of cultural change. This is further compounded by the challenge of working out how it can be governed, monitored and measured.

Lessons from starling murmuration

For many years, people have watched huge flocks of starlings gather and “dance” in astonishing formations in the evening sky. It is called “murmuration”. The starlings seem to react to emerging threats and risks as a single entity, moving in beautiful patterns, often confusing the attacking falcon, or whatever the threat may be. The result is that the whole flock is much safer. It can be observed that a change in behaviour of one bird affects and is affected by the behaviour of the whole group. This means it does not matter how big the flock is, they react in almost perfect synchronisation.

How do they achieve this?

Research suggests that each bird monitors several small and specific indicators from the birds closest to it in the flock, its “peer group”. It looks for tiny changes in things like distance, alignment, direction and acceleration. Starlings have very fast reactions and respond rapidly to these changes, but this does not explain how they react to threats on the other side of the flock.

A new theory is that alongside these quantifiable metrics they also continually assess patterns of light and shade caused by the bunching and swirling of the group. This gives them an understanding of where they are individually within the flock as it twists and turns. The result is an incredible speed of communication and agility. Each bird has a broad sense of where it is in the group and understands what the wider group is doing, and importantly, where it is going.

The flock can react collectively, as one, to new risks and threats, regardless of its size. This is the link to culture, in any medium-sized or large firm. Company culture has been described as a “shared set of norms that influence behaviour”, but many CEOs or chairs of the board might wish their “culture” to be as positively responsive and cohesive as a murmuration. If we compare starling murmuration with corporate governance and culture then there are insights we can take regarding developing, maintaining and measuring a cohesive and responsive “flock”.

These include:

  • Having a clearly defined and communicated cultural ambition (outcomes, tolerances and accountability) that all staff are aware of and understand.
  • Managing risk by improving people development, awareness and communication across first, second and third line defences.
  • Measuring and monitoring using key performance indicators (KPIs), key risk indicators (KRIs) and trends that support decision-making, raise alerts when corrective action is needed and help identify desired outcomes.

Most of this operational data can be viewed through a “cultural lens” and used to manage culture within the firm.

As Jonathan Davidson, FCA director of supervision — retail and authorisations, said in a recent speech: “culture in a firm is, in simple terms, ‘the way things get done around here'”. It naturally follows that operational management information, which reports on what is being done, can be used to monitor culture.

It is similar to the quantified metrics that each starling needs to keep in its place such as speed, direction and alignment. The real challenge for companies, however, is to identify and use the “patterns of light and dark” that make culture into an effective tool for improving performance and delivering good outcomes for customers and markets: making cultural development scale-free and correlated.

How can technology help?

This is where technology, the systems that support day-to-day activity across nearly all roles within a firm, can make a difference.

Increasingly, in modern life, we expect systems to help us. We are becoming used to Amazon telling us what to buy, Netflix telling us what to watch, or Google telling us what is new. The financial service regulators in the UK, the FCA and Prudential Regulation Authority (PRA), have made their focus on culture and conduct clear, and reconfirmed their increasing intent to enforce improvement in firms.

The individual accountability regime provides firms, and particularly individuals, with a clear set of rules and responsibilities that need to be adhered to, but by its very nature, the cultural aspect of the regime is less tangible.

This means that boards and executive teams, and on their behalf, risk and compliance functions, have a complicated job. They need to focus on and adapt to both the tangible and the less tangible aspects of ensuring they meet their regulatory requirements.

In addition, all three lines of defence — front-line, risk and compliance oversight and internal audit — also need to support and protect senior managers against the personal impact of non-compliance. In the same speech, Davidson said “… You [senior managers] are not just accountable for your own actions but — to a reasonable extent — for those who work for you.”

Technology provides solutions for implementing and holistically complying with SMCR and FCA governance and culture. As a minimum, your system(s) need to provide an auditable, accurate single point of truth. This enables strategic objectives and customer outcomes to be monitored through meaningful management information that can be produced quickly, efficiently and in real-time, which highlights the cultural indicators (the patterns of light and shade).

The pace and complexity of regulatory change means that risk and compliance functions face an increasing workload, often against a backdrop of rising cost pressures. Technology should be deployed to automate schedules and tasks that are currently performed manually. Technology should also proactively prompt and remind the relevant people of key activities, priorities and focus areas without the need for manual intervention.

People development and management is at the heart of cultural change. Systems can help to ensure that all staff are properly trained and equipped, and that they also understand the intersecting multiple culture and conduct initiatives that underpin cultural change. Under the SMCR, a senior manager will be made personally accountable for ensuring this happens (a prescribed responsibility).

Systems can do this by automatically flagging team members who need help, who need coaching or those who do not understand their responsibilities. Technology can empower your people to be more effective people managers.

It is perhaps counterintuitive, but many firms need to adopt new systems to help their people focus on their people. It is this focus on people and their behaviours which will deliver successful culture change and compliance with regulatory obligations. Cultural initiatives that introduce large administration burdens or “tick-box” evidence capture get in the way of, and often prevent, the changes they are intended to deliver.

Modern technology, sometimes referred to as ‘regtech’ in financial services, that is “technology designed to support compliance and mitigate the costs to regulation”, can efficiently and effectively deliver culture and conduct programmes. These people-centric regtech solutions can be easily tailored to your firm’s specific business and people processes.

This is a relatively new approach to regulation, so for many organisations it can be difficult to know where to start when implementing digital solutions to support compliant cultures. Our behavioural compliance infographic takes a closer look at the core behavioural factors that facilitate and sustain cultures of compliance and how they can be supported with technology.

Successful businesses are beginning to emulate starling murmurations by implementing systems that focus on their people and their behaviour, collate the relevant cultural messages and consistently distribute the message to everyone that needs it. This gives them the vital impression of light and shade as the firm evolves, making their alignment to the bigger picture clear.

Risk and compliance professionals need to assess whether they have the appropriate processes and control infrastructure in place to support their firm’s target culture and, if not, present a clear business case to implement it. Our software solution, Pentana Compliance, helps firms to manage competency and SMCR requirements, placing culture and governance at the centre of corporate activity. Find out more about how Ideagen can help your organisation embed a culture of compliance with our free behaviour science and compliance e-book.

Ideagen's Fraser Doig
Written by

Fraser Doig

As Product Marketing Executive at Ideagen, Fraser is responsible for understanding the needs of our customers and how our software can help them become leaders in their industry. Fraser brings to his role a desire to help organisations drive quality and control in their business processes as a way of achieving operational excellence.

Related blog posts

Here are some more blog posts that you might be interested in.

18 January 2021

A new approach to compliance: What is compliance culture?

by Sophie Willink

Compliance is crucial for businesses to ensure safety, integrity, and ethical behaviour at all levels of an organisation. However, for many business functions the mere mention of ‘compliance’ can evoke the wrong kind of emotion. To overcome this c...

Continue reading
03 February 2021

Behavioural compliance: Understanding how to shape a compliant culture

by Sophie Willink

Our previous blog started a conversation about rethinking organisational approaches to comp...

Continue reading

Find the best product for you

Use our product assistance tool and get recommendations based on your business needs.

My Business Need

This will help us identify the best software product for you.

Please select at least one business need

Tell Us More

Please share some further detail so we can refine your product recommendations.

Please select a type of risk
Previous
Solutions Quality Health, Safety & Environmental Audit & Risk Documents & Collaboration Company Leadership team Our objectives Strategy Investors Careers Vacancies We're hiring
Ideagen products Q-Pulse QMS Q-Pulse WorkRite Q-Pulse PM Q-Pulse Law Pentana Audit Pentana Disclose Pentana Risk PleaseReview Coruson Ideagen Academy Ideagen Academy CompliancePath Huddle Qualtrax Mi-Co InspectionXpert CompliSpace OpsBase Mail Manager Audit Analytics
Pentana Disclose Pentana Risk PleaseReview Coruson Ideagen Academy CompliancePath Huddle Qualtrax Mi-Co InspectionXpert CompliSpace OpsBase Mail Manager Audit Analytics
Company Leadership team Our objectives Strategy Investors Careers Vacancies We're hiring
Connect with us
© Ideagen Plc.
Privacy Policy Terms and conditions GDPR commitment Environmental policy Slavery and human traficking statement Sitemap